Astronauts For America Candidate Scorecard A plan to establish transparent, evidence-based criteria and metrics for evaluating candidates and public officials on their adherence to constitutional principles, civic responsibility, and evidence-based decision-making. Submitter's Note: This model performance plan has been prepared in dialog with ChatGPT to illustrate how the candidate scorecard referenced in a Wall Street Journal article might be documented in an open, standard, machine-readable format. The performance indicators are proposed for consideration and refinement by the organization and its stakeholders. ^^ Anyone who may wish to turn this model plan into a performance report could use the form at https://stratml.us/forms/Claude/Part2.html ^^ The article that stimulated this plan is available to WSJ subscribers at https://www.wsj.com/science/space-astronomy/worried-about-u-s-democracy-astronauts-are-launching-a-political-nonprofit-b210fb3a?st=hAPRm7 Astronauts For America AFA A coalition of former NASA astronauts committed to upholding constitutional values, restoring public trust, and promoting evidence-based decision-making in public service. An American democracy characterized by mutual respect, constitutional fidelity, and accountable leadership grounded in evidence and the rule of law. To promote civic responsibility and strengthen democratic institutions by evaluating and supporting leaders who respect constitutional principles, scientific evidence, and collaborative governance. Rule of Law Ensure that public officials act within constitutional limits and respect judicial authority and due process. Evidence Encourage policymaking grounded in verifiable data, scientific reasoning, and transparent analysis. Accountability Provide measurable criteria enabling citizens to evaluate the performance of elected officials and candidates. Candidate Evaluation Assess candidates and public officials using transparent, objective, and replicable performance indicators aligned with constitutional responsibilities and civic leadership standards. 89DDFF63-0A88-431B-B687-242C8B3F726B 1 Citizens Voters Beneficiary Astronauts For America Evaluator Performer Election Integrity Evaluate adherence to lawful election processes and support for the peaceful transfer of authority following certified election outcomes. DC808E89-C814-4FD4-849F-89CABCD7EB3B 1.1 1.1.1 Election Outcomes Percent Status 380135C3-6EB2-40FF-9772-8C490E0D5FE7 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 100 Acknowledged Certified election results are publicly acknowledged as legitimate TBD Results to be documented based on public statements and official records 1.1.2 Court Rulings Percentage Status 0B8E84A0-8673-4DAF-9ADC-A9EF53345418 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 100 Compliance Legal compliance with election-related court rulings as evidenced by lack of confirmed violations of lawful court orders Violations to be documented from court records Evidence-Based Policy Evaluate the extent to which candidates and public officials base policy positions and decisions on verifiable data, scientific reasoning, and transparent analytical methods. 5E1A1C0E-4C7E-4A1E-9E6A-9D0F7A8F2B11 1.2 1.2.1 Policy Evidence Percent Status F7C8A4A1-5E2D-4F91-A9B6-1E4C3F7C2D21 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 100 Documented Major policy positions are supported by publicly accessible data, research findings, or documented analysis. TBD Supporting evidence to be documented based on published policy statements, legislative records, and official communications. 1.2.2 Methodology Transparency Percent Status 2B4E7D33-1C72-4E54-A4D9-5A1C0F9E7A32 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 100 Published Analytical methods, assumptions, and sources underlying major policy proposals are publicly disclosed. TBD Transparency to be assessed based on availability of supporting documentation and explanatory materials. 1.2.3 Expert Consultation Percent Status 9A3F6B2E-8D5C-4C8A-9F11-3B7D5E6C4A43 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 100 Consulted Qualified subject-matter experts are consulted and their input documented in the development of major policy initiatives. TBD Consultation to be documented based on public records, advisory reports, and stakeholder disclosures. Congressional Engagement Evaluate the extent to which candidates and public officials actively participate in legislative responsibilities, collaborate across party lines, and exercise oversight consistent with constitutional duties. 3C9A9E7A-5F4D-4F8C-A6A3-2D7E9B6C1F21 1.3 1.3.1 Committee Attendance Percent Status 5B2F3C1D-9E6A-4D9F-A2C4-7F1E3A9B6C12 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 100 Participating Assigned committee sessions are attended as scheduled and participation is documented in official records. TBD Attendance to be documented based on congressional attendance records and committee reports. 1.3.2 Bipartisan Sponsorship Percent Status 1E7B4D9A-2C6F-4B8E-9D3A-6F2C5E7A1B33 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 100 Collaborating Legislative initiatives include documented collaboration with members representing different political affiliations. TBD Sponsorship to be documented based on legislative records and bill co-sponsorship data. 1.3.3 Oversight Actions Number Status 8D6A2F5C-4E1B-4C9F-A7D2-3B5E6C9A2F44 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 1 Conducted Oversight hearings, investigations, or formal reviews of executive actions are conducted consistent with constitutional responsibilities. TBD Oversight activities to be documented based on committee reports and official congressional records. Civic Education Evaluate the extent to which candidates and public officials promote public understanding of constitutional principles, civic responsibilities, and democratic processes through educational outreach and engagement. 7A4D1F3B-2E6C-4C9A-8F11-5D3B7E9C2A51 1.4 1.4.1 Education Events Number Status 2F8C5E7A-1B3D-4C9E-A6F2-8D1A3C7B5E62 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 1 Conducted At least one public civic education event or forum is conducted and documented during the reporting period. TBD Events to be documented based on public schedules, announcements, and participation records. 1.4.2 Educational Materials Number Status 9B2E6C4F-7A1D-4E8F-B3C2-6D5A7E9C1B73 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 1 Published Educational resources explaining civic responsibilities or constitutional principles are publicly published and accessible. TBD Materials to be documented based on publications, websites, or distributed educational content. 1.4.3 Youth Engagement Percent Status 5C7A2F9E-3D6B-4C1A-8E2F-7B9D4A6C2E84 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 100 Participating Opportunities for civic learning are made available to youth audiences through outreach, educational programming, or public engagement initiatives. TBD Participation to be documented based on attendance records, program enrollment, or engagement statistics. Cross-Sector Trust Evaluate the extent to which candidates and public officials foster trust across sectors by engaging diverse stakeholders, facilitating open dialogue, and maintaining constructive relationships among institutions and communities. 4F7B1C2D-6A9E-4C8F-B3D1-2E5A7C9F6B15 1.5 1.5.1 Stakeholder Dialogues Number Status 8E2A4C9D-1F6B-4A3E-9C2D-7F5A1B6E3D21 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 1 Conducted At least one structured dialogue involving representatives from different sectors is conducted and documented. TBD Dialogues to be documented based on meeting records, public notices, and stakeholder participation logs. 1.5.2 Public Forums Number Status 1C6D9A2E-5B4F-4C7A-A9D3-6E2B7F5C1A32 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 1 Held Public forums enabling open discussion of civic issues are organized and made accessible to community members. TBD Forums to be documented based on event schedules, attendance records, and public communications. 1.5.3 Trust Surveys Percent Status 7B3E2C5A-9F1D-4C6B-A8E4-3D9A7F2C6B43 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 100 Completed Public trust levels are measured through surveys or feedback mechanisms and results are documented. TBD Survey results to be documented based on published findings and verified data sources. Participation Evaluate the extent to which candidates and public officials encourage and support active participation in democratic processes by voters, volunteers, and community members. 2E7C5F1A-9D3B-4C8E-A6F2-5B1D7E9C4A61 1.6 1.6.1 Voter Participation Percent Status 6F3A1C9E-4D7B-4E2C-A8F1-9C5E7B2D3A12 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 100 Participating Eligible voters are provided opportunities and encouragement to participate in elections and civic activities. TBD Participation to be documented based on official turnout statistics and verified civic engagement records. 1.6.2 Volunteer Engagement Number Status 9A2F6C4E-1D5B-4C8A-B7F3-2E6D9C1A5B23 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 1 Supported Volunteer opportunities supporting civic engagement or community participation are established and documented. TBD Volunteer engagement to be documented based on participation records and organizational reports. 1.6.3 Public Feedback Number Status 5C8E2B7A-3D1F-4C9A-A6E2-7B5D1F9C4E34 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 1 Collected Mechanisms for collecting public input on civic issues are established and feedback is documented. TBD Feedback to be documented based on surveys, public comments, or stakeholder submissions. Candidate Support Evaluate the extent to which qualified candidates demonstrating adherence to constitutional principles and evidence-based governance are identified, endorsed, and supported through lawful and transparent processes. 8F3A6D1C-2E5B-4C9A-A7D2-6B1F9E4C2A71 1.7 1.7.1 Candidate Identification Number Status 4C7A2F9E-6B1D-4E3C-A8F2-9D5A1B7C3E12 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 1 Documented At least one candidate meeting established evaluation criteria is formally identified and documented. TBD Identification to be documented based on candidate evaluations and publicly available records. 1.7.2 Candidate Endorsement Number Status 1D6B9A3C-5F2E-4C8A-B7D1-3E9C6A2F5B23 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 1 Issued A formal endorsement decision is issued for at least one candidate based on documented evaluation criteria. TBD Endorsements to be documented based on official organizational announcements and public communications. 1.7.3 Campaign Assistance Number Status 7B2E5C1A-9D3F-4C6A-A8E1-5D7C2F9B6E34 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 1 Provided Lawful assistance supporting a candidate's campaign is provided and documented in compliance with applicable regulations. TBD Assistance to be documented based on campaign finance disclosures and organizational records. Civic Engagement Strengthen public understanding of democratic institutions and promote constructive civic participation through outreach, dialogue, and educational initiatives that reinforce constitutional governance and mutual respect. 6C2F1A9E-4D7B-4C8A-B5E3-9F2D7A1C4B81 2 Citizens Participants Beneficiary Community Organizations Partners Public Outreach Promote public awareness of civic responsibilities and democratic processes through structured outreach activities that encourage informed participation in community and national affairs. 2D5B7A1C-9E4F-4C8A-A6D3-5F2E9C1A7B92 2.1 2.1.1 Outreach Events Number Status 9E1C4B7A-3D5F-4C8A-B2E6-1A9D7C2F5B13 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 1 Conducted At least one public outreach event is conducted to promote civic participation and understanding of democratic processes. TBD Outreach activities to be documented based on event schedules, participation records, and public communications. 2.1.2 Audience Awareness Percent Status 5B2F7C1A-9D4E-4C8A-A3F6-7E2C1B9D5A24 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 100 Informed Participants demonstrate increased awareness of civic responsibilities and democratic processes following outreach activities. TBD Awareness levels to be documented based on participant feedback, surveys, or follow-up engagement metrics. Community Dialogue Facilitate constructive dialogue among members of the public and other stakeholder groups in order to strengthen mutual understanding, surface civic concerns, and encourage collaborative problem solving. 7D2B4F1A-8E3C-4C9A-A6D1-5B7E2C9F4A93 2.2 Citizens Participants Beneficiary Community Organizations Participants Beneficiary 2.2.1 Dialogue Sessions Number Status 3A7E1C5B-9D2F-4C8A-B6E3-1F9C7A2D5B14 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 1 Conducted At least one structured community dialogue session is conducted and documented during the reporting period. TBD Dialogue sessions to be documented based on event records, agendas, and participation logs. 2.2.2 Stakeholder Representation Number Status 8F1C4A7D-2E5B-4C9A-A3F6-7D2B1E9C5A25 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 2 Included At least two distinct stakeholder groups are represented in each documented dialogue session. TBD Representation to be documented based on attendee lists and stakeholder classifications. 2.2.3 Issue Resolution Number Status 5C9A2E7B-1D4F-4C8A-B7E2-6A3D9F1C4B36 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 1 Advanced At least one civic issue or proposed action is advanced through documented dialogue and follow-up. TBD Progress to be documented based on meeting summaries, action items, or follow-up communications. Civic Learning Strengthen public understanding of constitutional governance, civic responsibilities, and democratic processes through accessible educational resources and structured learning opportunities. 9B7D3E1C-4F2A-4C8A-A6D5-2E9C7A1F5B94 2.3 Students Learners Beneficiary Educators Facilitators 2.3.1 Learning Resources Number Status 2E4C9A7B-1D5F-4C8A-B7E2-6A3D9F1C4B37 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 1 Published At least one educational resource explaining civic responsibilities or constitutional principles is publicly published and accessible. TBD Resources to be documented based on publication records and distribution channels. 2.3.2 Learning Sessions Number Status 5F1A7C3E-9D2B-4C8A-A6F4-1C9E7A2D5B48 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 1 Delivered At least one structured learning session or educational program is delivered to support civic knowledge and engagement. TBD Sessions to be documented based on attendance records, schedules, and participant feedback. 2.3.3 Knowledge Gain Percent Status 7A2D5B9C-3E1F-4C8A-B6D2-9E4C1A7F5B59 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 100 Demonstrated Participants demonstrate increased understanding of civic responsibilities and democratic processes following learning activities. TBD Knowledge gain to be documented based on assessments, surveys, or participant evaluations. Civic Collaboration Encourage cooperative efforts among community members and institutions to address civic challenges, share resources, and advance constructive solutions through coordinated action. A1E4C7B9-5D2F-4C8A-A6E3-7F1C9D2B5A95 2.4 Community Members Collaborators Beneficiary Civic Leaders Conveners 2.4.1 Partnership Agreements Number Status 4C9A7E2B-1D5F-4C8A-B7E3-2F9C1A6D5B61 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 1 Established At least one formal collaboration agreement among stakeholders is established and documented. TBD Agreements to be documented based on memoranda of understanding, partnership records, or joint announcements. 2.4.2 Joint Initiatives Number Status 7F2A5C1E-9D4B-4C8A-A6F2-5E1C9A3D7B72 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 1 Launched At least one coordinated civic initiative involving multiple stakeholders is launched and publicly documented. TBD Initiatives to be documented based on project plans, public communications, and implementation records. 2.4.3 Collaborative Outcomes Number Status 9E1B4C7D-2F5A-4C8A-B6E1-3D9C7A2F5B83 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 1 Achieved At least one measurable improvement or solution resulting from collaborative civic action is documented. TBD Outcomes to be documented based on project evaluations, reports, or verified performance results. Civic Participation Encourage and document active involvement by members of the public in civic activities that strengthen democratic institutions and community problem solving. B3D7A1C5-4E9F-4C8A-A6E2-8F1C9D2B5A96 2.5 Residents Participants Beneficiary Volunteers Contributors 2.5.1 Event Participation Number Status 6A2E9C1B-5F4D-4C8A-B7E1-3D9A7F2C5B74 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 1 Recorded Participation in at least one civic event is documented and publicly reported. TBD Participation to be documented based on attendance records and public reports. 2.5.2 Volunteer Involvement Number Status 1F7C4B9E-2D5A-4C8A-A6E3-9B1D7C2F5A85 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 1 Documented Volunteer involvement in civic initiatives is documented and publicly recognized. TBD Volunteer activity to be documented based on participation logs and organizational records. 2.5.3 Public Contributions Number Status 9C5A2E7B-4D1F-4C8A-B6E2-7A3D9F1C5B96 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 1 Submitted At least one public contribution, recommendation, or proposal is submitted and documented for civic consideration. TBD Contributions to be documented based on submitted comments, proposals, or public input records. Governance and Accountability Promote transparent, ethical, and responsible governance by documenting performance, disclosing decision-making processes, and maintaining accountability to the public and other stakeholders. 8E4C7A1D-5B2F-4C8A-A6E1-9F3D7A2C5B97 3 Citizens Oversight Participants Beneficiary Public Officials Accountable Parties Performer Transparency Ensure that decisions, actions, and performance results are openly documented and accessible to the public in formats that enable independent review and informed participation. 3A9F2C7E-1D5B-4C8A-B6E3-7F2A9C1D5B98 3.1 3.1.1 Public Reports Number Status 5D7A1C9E-4F2B-4C8A-A6E2-1B9C7A3D5F99 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 1 Published At least one comprehensive public performance report is published and made accessible to stakeholders. TBD Reports to be documented based on publication records and public availability. 3.1.2 Data Availability Percent Status 9F2C7A1D-5B3E-4C8A-A6E1-7D2A9C5B1E10 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 100 Accessible Relevant performance data are made publicly accessible in formats that enable analysis and reuse. TBD Availability to be documented based on public records and system access logs. Ethical Conduct Promote adherence to ethical standards by documenting compliance with codes of conduct, disclosing potential conflicts of interest, and maintaining integrity in public decision-making. 6F3A1C9E-4D7B-4C8A-A6E2-9C5E7B2D3A11 3.2 Public Officials Ethics Participants Performer Oversight Bodies Reviewers 3.2.1 Ethics Compliance Percent Status 1A7B4D9E-2C6F-4C8A-B7E3-5F1E9C2D7A21 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 100 Compliant Applicable ethical standards and codes of conduct are followed and documented by responsible parties. TBD Compliance to be documented based on ethics filings, certifications, and official records. 3.2.2 Conflict Disclosure Percent Status 9E2C7A1D-5B3F-4C8A-A6E1-7D2A9C5B1E22 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 100 Disclosed Potential conflicts of interest are fully disclosed and documented in accordance with applicable requirements. TBD Disclosures to be documented based on public filings and verified reporting systems. 3.2.3 Code Adherence Percent Status 4C9A7E2B-1D5F-4C8A-B7E3-2F9C1A6D5B23 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 100 Maintained Established ethical codes and professional standards are consistently followed in official conduct. TBD Adherence to be documented based on oversight reviews and compliance assessments. Performance Reporting Document and publish performance information in a timely, accurate, and verifiable manner to support accountability, informed decision-making, and public trust. 2C7E4A1D-9B5F-4C8A-A6E2-3F1D7C9A5B24 3.3 Citizens Information Users Beneficiary Auditors Reviewers 3.3.1 Report Timeliness Percent Status 7A1C9E4D-5B2F-4C8A-B7E3-1F9C2D7A5B35 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 100 Submitted Required performance reports are submitted and published within established reporting deadlines. TBD Timeliness to be documented based on publication dates and reporting schedules. 3.3.2 Data Accuracy Percent Status 5B3E7A1C-9D4F-4C8A-A6E1-2F7C9A5B4D46 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 100 Verified Reported data are reviewed and verified for completeness and accuracy prior to publication. TBD Accuracy to be documented based on validation checks and audit findings. 3.3.3 Results Verification Percent Status 9C2D7A1F-4B5E-4C8A-B6E2-7A3F1D9C5B57 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 100 Confirmed Performance results are independently reviewed or otherwise confirmed using reliable evidence. TBD Verification to be documented based on audit reports, evaluations, or independent assessments. Continuous Improvement Identify opportunities for improvement, implement corrective actions, and document measurable gains in performance to strengthen accountability and organizational effectiveness over time. 4B7E1C9A-2D5F-4C8A-A6E3-9F1D7C2A5B58 3.4 Program Managers Improvement Leaders Performer Stakeholders Feedback Providers 3.4.1 Improvement Actions Number Status 1F9C2D7A-5B3E-4C8A-B6E2-7A3F1D9C5B59 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 1 Implemented At least one documented improvement action is implemented to address identified performance gaps or opportunities. TBD Actions to be documented based on improvement plans, corrective action reports, or performance reviews. 3.4.2 Corrective Measures Number Status 7A3F1D9C-5B2E-4C8A-A6E1-9F2D7C1A5B60 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 1 Completed Corrective measures addressing identified deficiencies are completed and documented. TBD Measures to be documented based on corrective action records and verification reports. 3.4.3 Performance Gains Percent Status 9F2D7C1A-5B3E-4C8A-B6E2-7A3F1D9C5B61 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 100 Improved Measurable improvement in performance indicators is documented following implementation of corrective actions. TBD Gains to be documented based on comparative performance results and evaluation findings. 2026-01-01 2026-12-31 2026-04-21 https://stratml.us/docs/AFACS.xml Owen Ambur Owen.Ambur@verizon.net